2008-Ohio-565 Cincinnati Ins. Co. v. Robert W. Setterlin Sons. No. 2007-2094.Supreme Court of Ohio. February 20, 2008. Franklin App. No. 07AP-47, 2007-Ohio-5094. APPEALS ACCEPTED FOR REVIEW. MOYER, C.J., would accept the appeal on Proposition of Law No. I only. PFEIFER and CUPP, JJ., dissent. Tagged: 2008-Ohio-565